On Matters That Matter

The man who removes a mountain begins by carrying away small stones

Archive for September 2018

The hubris of poor travellers

leave a comment »

The brilliant Anderson
A 4-1 series loss is a 4-1 series loss. Statements from Captain Virat Kohli and Coach Ravi Shastri undermine the fact that there’s no hiding place on a cricket field or in any other sport for that matter. The aggressive Kohli’s statements in the press conference after the fifth Test were extremely defensive in nature. To paraphrase, he said that the scoreline of 4-1 to England didn’t show how competitive the series was, and that both the teams and those who understand cricket know it. Add to this the fact that Shastri said that the current crop of players are travelling much better than the teams of the last 15-20 years and you get a perfect example of the team management’s hubris.
If Shastri wasn’t speaking metaphorically then it means that this crop is better than any settled side that toured outside India 1998 onwards. Under Kohli India has won 9 matches away from home (5 against Sri Lanka, 2 against West Indies, 1 each against South Africa and England) and lost 8 (1 against Australia and Sri Lanka, 2 against South Africa and 4 against England). We have had series wins in Sri Lanka many times before Kohli took over and have registered series wins against much better sides than the West Indies that the current crop defeated. We’ve never won a series in Australia or South Africa and the best result of a drawn series in both the countries came with the crop Kohli grew up admiring. To put forth my brutally honest opinion, we could have ticked Australia twice, under Ganguly and then under Kumble but were denied both times by Umpire Steve Bucknor (It wasn’t about just one decision but several in Sydney in Steve Waugh’s last Test when Shastri was in the commentators box and remarked whether the Umpires were given a great breakfast for extending favour after favour and Mark Waugh and some other Australian commentators agreed). The second was too acrimonious to talk about but had that massive edge of Andrew Symonds who rescued Australia in the first essay been given, India would have had a decent chance of closing out the game.
There have been close encounters with South Africa as well but no blame can be laid on being hard done by bad decisions. The South Africans have defended their turf brilliantly. We were 1-0 ahead under Dravid but lost the 3 Test series 2-1 where the last Test was tantalizingly close where Zaheer Khan made getting 10 runs look like 40 and a needless change in the batting order that had succeeded in the first innings led to our undoing in the second. We came from being 0-1 behind to level the series under Dhoni when we were the number 1 Test side in the world rankings. The final Test was a brilliant draw, the first time we drew a series in SA, with Steyn bowling what is known as the ‘spell from hell’ and Tendulkar scoring a brilliant 51st Test hundred. It was Kallis who denied India on both the occasions, a very cautious and defensive partnership in a low-scoring chase with Ashwell Prince the first time round when we lost and a hundred in both innings to save the game when Harbhajan had left them reeling in the second innings under Dhoni’s leadership.
These were performances to be proud of and where a little bit of luck could have led to India recording series wins. We fought extremely well in South Africa under Dravid and Dhoni and in Australia under Ganguly and Kumble with the series being competitive till the last Test match. Under Dravid we also won a series in England but to be fair to Bucknor he did rule a plumb leg before in our favour at Lord’s else the series would have been a 1-1 draw.
The current crop is not battle hardened and they meekly surrendered against a struggling English side. They chopped and changed too much and got the combination completely wrong in the first two Tests against South Africa and England. Two wins and six losses against relatively beatable sides is not a record that qualifies this team to be labeled as the best travellers in the last 15-20 years. They might actually be somewhere near the bottom. The best player is not always the best person to lead the side, so we must at least ponder if a change is needed there—Rahane displayed a very cool demeanour in the Test where we won against Australia at home and wrapped the series as well. As for the head coach, a change is surely needed.

Advertisements

Written by Deepan Joshi

September 13, 2018 at 12:15 pm

%d bloggers like this: